There is a lot of good to share about this restaurant. Service (Walter) was awesome. The bread app and French Onion soup were solid starters. The garlic mashed potatoes could be shared comfortably by 4 people and were also delicious. My husband mostly enjoyed* the Delmonico Ribeye with the Bearnaise sauce. One note is that the sauce is on your steak, it's not a side.Why 4 stars? *Both steaks were pretty fatty, but not the awesome, melt-in-your-mouth kind. The kind where you don't know where to go with the mouthful in polite company. I chose not to eat the NY Strip and will not order it again.Also, it was noted on the reservation that it was my husbands birthday and there wasn't even a "happy birthday" mention.Bottom line - try it. We will likely give it another chance when we are back in Indianapolis again, however, for us it doesn't make the top 10 for steak experiences around the country.

The steak was legit medium rare BUT the outside of the steak was not properly seared and so not much of a crust. The sweet corn side was yummy (don’t know the exact name).

This is the best steakhouse in Indy/Carmel. I have been to all of the high end steakhouses in Indiana, and Prime is the best! The price is reasonable, service top notch, and the food is always fantastic. I have been there 5 times in the last 6 months the only place even close is Geraldine’s Supper Club, and that is too far from Carmel. Go to Prime, you will not regret it